The United States Does Not . . . Uh, It Didn't Happen This Time

Effluvia

Iranian scientist and former would-be defector Shahram Amiri has returned to Iran, and spun a story about being subjected to the "harshest mental and physical torture" in the United States, aided (of course, since this statement was for consumption in Iran and the Middle East) by Israeli agents and the threat of deportation to some grim fate in Israel.

The entire story sounds patently bogus, in that (1) we let him go relatively quickly and voluntarily, and (2) he's clearly someone we wanted information from, and (3) we're being pretty open about it. I don't believe him — the facts and circumstances suggest that it's a publicity stunt by Iran, with his willing participation.

But it got me thinking. Wouldn't it be nice if we could respond to his statement by saying, "Unlike Iran, the United States of America does not torture. And we don't ship people off to cooperative foreign countries to be tortured, nor do we threaten to do so."

But I guess we can still make a case-by-case defense.

Last 5 posts by Ken

2 Comments

2 Comments

  1. mojo  •  Jul 15, 2010 @1:03 pm

    How about "We don't torture people who are actively helping us deter Iran from becoming a wild-card nuclear power like North Korea. But we generally don't stuff 5 mil into their bank accounts either. This guy was very helpful. Hope they don't hang his whole family.."?

  2. Doug  •  Jul 15, 2010 @4:30 pm

    I wonder what will happen when he returns home?