Ten Books

Books

A number of bloggers I respect have begun playing Tyler Cowen's "Desert Island Discs" game, with books. I thought I'd play along.  In no particular order, these are the books that (I think) had the greatest influence on who I am.

1.  Fedor Dostoevsky, Crime and Punishment.  If a novel can capture the problem of evil and atonement, this is the one.  Unlike Dostoevsky, I am not a Christian, but one doesn't need to be to draw from the story of Raskolnikov's murder, torture through guilt, and reform.

2. Douglas Hofstadter, Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid.  This book taught me not so much about music or mathematics, but led me to think about the way I discover and appreciate beauty.

3. Thomas Sowell, Knowledge and Decisions.  Sowell the newspaper columnist is a polemicist and not a favorite.  But I thank him for this book, which still informs my thinking on economics and the unintended consequences of acting with the best intentions.

4. Alexander Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago.  I read this more as a moral story of suffering and redemption, Dostoevsky writing about a nation rather than a man.  But I won't deny that it powerfully influenced my views on politics and human nature.

5. Francois Truffaut, Hitchcock / Truffaut. This is my favorite book about my favorite form of art, and a witty series of interviews between a master of film, and a student who would go on to become a master himself.

6. Mark Z. Danielewski, House of Leaves. A film within a magic realist novel, the magic realist novel that Dave Eggers wishes he could write.  Eggers was never this clever, while Marquez was never this strange.  My friend Triggercut, whose real name I don't know but who occasionally reads this blog, recommended this book to me, for which I thank him.

7. Robert Anton Wilson and Robert Shea, Illuminatus! More than anything else on this list, Wilson and Shea's satire of conspiracy theory, with a touch of Arthur Clarke, H. P. Lovecraft, and James Joyce, made me the paranoiac that I am today.

8. Raymond Chandler, Farewell My Lovely.  This is perhaps a stand-in for Chandler as a whole, and a host of equally worthy writers toiling in the same pulp noir sweatshop, but of all of the great work that highbrows dismiss as "genre fiction," Chandler's second Philip Marlowe novel is my favorite.

9. William Blake, Songs of Innocence and of Experience. If I did have to go to a desert island, and could bring only one book, it would be a Blake collection. These poems are best read together, accompanied by Blake's etchings.

10. David Maurer, The Big Con: The Story of the Confidence Man.  I ask questions, and listen to answers, for a living.  This book, a collection of short stories disguised as a linguistics monograph, taught me to really listen to the answers people give me.  Not to listen as in "to understand," but as in "to appreciate the glory of spoken American English."

I'd encourage my co-bloggers to participate in this project, should they be so inclined, as I'd love to read and discuss their lists.

Via Angus.

Last 5 posts by Patrick

14 Comments

13 Comments

  1. Grandy  •  Mar 23, 2010 @8:20 pm

    I have turned House of Leaves over in my head many times since I read it. It will sound hyperbollic, but it got under my skin when I read it and I didn't sleep well at that time.

    My biggest problem with your list is the lack of [i]A Wrinkle in Time[/i].

  2. Patrick  •  Mar 23, 2010 @9:15 pm

    I look forward to reading your own list Grandy.

  3. Chris  •  Mar 24, 2010 @8:00 am

    House of Leaves has been on my short list for a long time, largely because of recommendations received by people on this site. I keep not getting to it.

  4. Matt Raft  •  Mar 24, 2010 @10:49 am

    Never heard of House of Leaves before–glad to hear about a new book, but sometimes the hype doesn't meet expectations. I had to put down Roberto Bolano's Savage Detectives after trying my best to get through it. (If I want to read Norman Mailer, I'll read him and not a South American copycat.) Anyway, here's my list of best books:

    http://willworkforjustice.blogspot.com/2009/11/my-most-influential-books.html

  5. Patrick  •  Mar 24, 2010 @11:01 am

    This is a no-spin zone Matt. Each of these books (and the poem cycle/art piece by Blake) is deeply important to me.

    Speaking of your list, have you read Robert Graves' Goodbye To All That? I'd recommend it as a companion to All Quiet On The Western Front.

  6. Ima Wurdibitsch  •  Mar 24, 2010 @12:24 pm

    House of Leaves is on my bookshelf and it's on my short list of books to read soon. Mark Danielewski's sister is the recording artist, Poe, and she refers to the House of Leaves in her album "Haunted." Excellent album with lyrics that reach out and grab you by the heart, shake you until your brains rattle, and then soothe all of the discomfort.

    As for the book list, I'm going to have to think long and hard about that but look forward to doing it.

  7. Mike  •  Mar 24, 2010 @1:12 pm

    I'd love to be able to say that I'd read any of the books on that list, but I haven't. And I probably won't.

  8. Dwight Brown  •  Mar 24, 2010 @2:10 pm

    I'm happy to say I've read four on Patrick's list (Hofstadter, Solzhenitsyn, Chandler, and Maurer) and I have Hitchcock / Truffaut but have not gotten around to reading it yet.

    I've responded on my own blog, too.

  9. Chris  •  Mar 24, 2010 @2:35 pm

    I read Illuminatus! when I was in high school. It had been this legendary rumored book for me (our library sucked and there was no book store in the town I grew up in, so I had to find it during out of state travel), and it didn't live up to my expectations. I don't know how it could have.

    Gödel, Escher, Bach is a lovely book. I had the priviledge of loaning it to my grandmother, a music teacher, towards the end of the time where she could appreciate such things.

  10. Little Raven  •  Mar 24, 2010 @2:58 pm

    Love House of Leaves.

    Ashamed to admit it's the only book on this list that I've read.

  11. Tscott  •  Mar 24, 2010 @7:42 pm

    When I'm asked about my favorite book, I usually cheat and give two answers; a fiction and a non-fiction book.

    I'm so glad to see my two answers get so much love:
    House of Leaves
    Gödel, Escher, Bach

    I discovered GEB in high school and it took my love of puzzles and paradox to a whole new level. Later when I found out about House of Leaves, it too took my love of puzzles and paradox someplace it hadn't gone before- this time into one of my favorite book genres; horror. I've reread both several times and will often find myself mulling over one or the other when my mind's otherwise idle. And at least once a year (usually after reading someone else's thoughts about it online) I drag out my copy of House of Leaves and look over the few pages of my notes I've stuck in it- containing different codes I've found inside the book and some of my random thoughts.

  12. Matt Raft  •  Mar 25, 2010 @2:42 am

    Patrick, I will add Robert Graves’ Goodbye To All That? to my list of books to read. Speaking of anti-war books, I am reading _The Things They Carried_, which is quite good.

  13. RLMullen  •  Mar 25, 2010 @11:15 am

    Times like this remind me that I really am one of the unwashed masses.

1 Trackback