“I Understand You Think It’s Not Fair, But So What?”

Politics & Current Events

That great moment of jurisprudence was brought to you by Chief Judge Alex Kozinski of the Ninth Circuit. He was referring to allegations that the Bush Obama  (sorry, they look so much alike..) administration is using threats of National Security to conceal crimes committed by the CIA as part of the extreme rendition program. This suit has been in and out of courts, and was only recently revived on appeal.

Interestingly, the administration plans to try the 9/11 plotters in open court using many of the same facts, and has talked about torture in the past. So, what made this so much more top secret?

How much longer is Obama going to talk about how different he is than Bush, while keeping many of the policies and sense of Imperial presidency that were Shrub’s hallmarks?

I also find Judge Kozinski’s attitude (as demonstrated by the quote in the title) that the administration should decide what is secret a little scary. Isn’t the whole point of Judicial Review to keep the government from doing just that?

Last 5 posts by Ezra

4 Comments

4 Comments

  1. TomH  •  Dec 16, 2009 @1:32 pm

    Let’s try this again –

    That wasn’t Bush that was acting extra-Constitutionally in the name of national security – it was Obama. Totally, totally different.

  2. Ronald Pottol  •  Dec 16, 2009 @7:23 pm

    I keep wondering when the states secrets precedent is going to get overturned. After all, the secrets in the original case are declassified, and the gov was lying, there were no real secrets involved.

    The idea that there are things so secret a judge cannot even review the materiel in a place of the governments choosing is absurd.

  3. Scott Jacobs  •  Dec 16, 2009 @8:20 pm

    Though in a more general sense, the judge has a point.

    “Fair” has little to do with life, and just because you don’t think something is fair, it doesn’t really mean much.

  4. mojo  •  Dec 17, 2009 @10:25 am

    Anything a proggie does is fair, by definition.

    Just ask ‘em.

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>