Disorientation Affecting Someone Who Is Suddenly Exposed To An Unfamiliar Way Of Life.

Gaming, Geekery

That’s one definition for the term “culture shock”.

Experts have said that some massively multiplayer online games, in which players battle enemies for weapons and rewards, are as addictive as crack cocaine.

Dr Richard Graham, a consultant psychiatrist at the Tavistock Centre in London, is so concerned that he plans to provide online therapy for youngsters who are spending so much time playing these games that they have lost touch with the real world.

In the real world, as opposed to the World of Warcraft, there are thousands of problems and maladies far more insidious and threatening than a 40 man dragon, where a good psychiatrist could volunteer his time.  Something tells me that Dr. Richard Graham is fishing for a grant, or a television gig, or a slot on a parliamentary advisory board.  Call me cynical.

But if he follows through Dr. Graham is about to get a lesson in culture shock.  He might characterize World of Warcraft players (among whom I number, level 72 on a character created in April and progressing to 80 without playing a Death Knight, thank you very much) as victims who have been entrapped by an online Skinner Box, where virtual community prestige and the rewards of “leveling” and online property replace the pellet.  He intends to enter the World of Warcraft, to save its addicted players from themselves.

World of Warcraft players on the other hand, who may suffer from the false consciousness of not wanting to be saved, might characterize Dr. Richard Graham as a clueless n00b who should be ganked as often as possible, or a sucker who could be scammed into buying this sweet Spectral Tiger Mount code I just happen to have.  He’ll probably play a Priest, with half his talents spread around the Holy tree, and the other half in Shadow.  And he’ll stand in the flames, if he ever gets that far.

I just long to meet Dr. Richard Graham, some late night, alone, at the Arathi Basin blacksmith node, so that he can educate my Felguard about the perils of addiction while I educate him about the perils of Shadow Bolt.  Anyway:

Dr Graham said that some players were so addicted to these massively multiplayer online games that they played them for up to 16 hours a day, leading them to neglect their social lives and education.

He has called on Blizzard Entertainment, the company that makes World of Warcraft, to waive or discount the costs associated with joining the game so that therapists can more easily communicate with at-risk players in their preferred environment.

“We will be launching this project by the end of the year. I think it’s already clear that psychiatrists will have to stay within the parameters of the game. They certainly wouldn’t be wandering around the game in white coats and would have to use the same characters available to other players,” said Dr Graham.

“Of course one problem we’re going to have to overcome is that while a psychiatrist may excel in what they do in the real world, they’re probably not going to be very good at playing World of Warcraft.

You don’t say, Dr. Graham?  While I think it unlikely that Blizzard is about to give Dr. Graham a free account, I do agree with him that most of his staff are going to be horrible at playing the game.  They’ll manage their talents unwisely. They’ll stand in the flames.  They’ll spam Barrens chat asking about Mankrik’s wife.  That is, when they’re not spamming Alliance /trade with messages like, “Addicted to World of Warcraft?  Feeling there’s a larger world out there you’re missing?  Talk to me.  I’m a trained psychiatrist.  I’m here to help.”

The odds of that working out are roughly equivalent to those of Michelle Pfeiffer showing up at a downtrodden inner city high school, and succeeding in her goal of teaching gang members about Dylan Thomas.

Or worse,  some small subset of Dr. Graham’s staff might actually learn to play.  They might become good at the game.  They might, like an addict savoring his crack, come to enjoy it.

Who will save them?

Last 5 posts by Patrick

18 Comments

17 Comments

  1. Patrick  •  Jul 28, 2009 @11:27 am

    And of course the Google adsense on the Telegraph article I linked is now showing an ad for Evony. They’re everywhere.

  2. Mike  •  Jul 28, 2009 @12:38 pm

    That’s what I hate about psychology. So much if it is dressed-up morality. “We don’t LIKE that you LIKE video games.” So fucking what? People like what they like.

    If I want to sit around eating Oreos, playing video games, why is that unhealthy? Because it does not comport with some psychologist’s value judgments about the world?

    Psychology is religion for atheists.

  3. Mike D  •  Jul 28, 2009 @3:22 pm

    I blame you for getting me re-hooked on WoW two or three years ago, then quitting about a month later. I’m going to have Graham send you the bill for my therapy.

  4. Patrick  •  Jul 28, 2009 @4:08 pm

    Don’t even try the new expansion Mike D. The raiding / dungeon end game is far more accessible to ordinary people who work for a living now, and therefore more highly addictive.

  5. Patrick  •  Jul 28, 2009 @4:11 pm

    Oh, and they’ve cut the leveling curve, to make it easier for players who quit two years ago (as I did), to get back into things even if they don’t remember the name or email address of the old account. They’ve even made travel easier. On the patch that drops next week, players can buy and train mounts at 20, and flying mounts at level 60.

    No, don’t get back into it. Especially not on Wyrmrest Accord server, where I’d buy your first mount for free.

  6. Scott Jacobs  •  Jul 28, 2009 @5:33 pm

    I really hope Wyrmrest is a PvP server… Because If it’s PvE, I would have to ask what faction you’re in, and if you know anyone who could part with a WoW disc and the expansion packs…

    And none of us want that…

  7. Patrick  •  Jul 28, 2009 @6:17 pm

    PvE server.

    Always Horde. I loathe the Alliance.

  8. Alaska  •  Jul 28, 2009 @9:22 pm

    I stopped playing about 6 months ago. Had a lvl 77 druid (horde, of course – I, too, loathe the Alliance. Named him Vonmises. Since I have my own office, I could play when things got slow. Things haven’t been slow, though, and I just sort of fell out of playing.

    I bet that shrink would be Alliance, which means he would be trying to work on 13 year old kids.

    For the Horde!

  9. Professor Coldheart  •  Jul 29, 2009 @6:17 am

    As a (non-online) gamer myself, I have a sick fascination with the way that WoW has balanced the effort/reward curve. If it’s not perfect, it’s the closest thing the entertainment industry has come to.

  10. Brandon  •  Jul 29, 2009 @11:26 am

    I think Patrick has the right of this: sai Graham is likely looking for funding, a book deal, or recognition. I’ve rambled at length on The-Board-That-Shall-Not-Be-Named about the ridiculousness of electronic-media addiction, and won’t repeat it here.

    I do feel compelled to add that, as a psychologist, I consider this kind of grandstanding as somewhere conceptually between ambulance-chasing and tinfoil-hat wearing. Most of the psychologists I know wince when stuff like this comes out. It’s hard enough helping people with problems without this kind of press making us come off as a bunch of busybodies.

  11. Chris  •  Jul 29, 2009 @12:48 pm

    I keep thinking about joining back in, but I don’t think anyone’s still playing with the hordenance crew, and I really don’t want to start over from the beginning.

  12. EdinMiama  •  Jul 29, 2009 @6:01 pm

    72? Pffft noob. :)

  13. Kimberly  •  Jul 30, 2009 @8:30 am

    I found you because I Googled Dr. Graham after reading about his crusade. Which is exactly what it is.

    From where would he get his referrals? Woe be the doctor who has the nerve to approach me and say in a whisper s/he thinks I’m “at-risk” because s/he’s seen me ingame the last few nights.

    Of course if they all rolled Undead and hung around with the Apothecary Faction it’d be a bit more palatable.

    Lok’tar ogar!
    Akromah of Hyjal

  14. Donna  •  Jul 30, 2009 @1:13 pm

    It’s not psychology that says we don’t LIKE that you LIKE to play games, that would be sociology. I am in school now to become a counselor, and I play WoW. I think it would be a good idea to offer this option in game, because how many of your guildies do you know who are so tired after raiding on a Tuesday Night they are exhausted for work Wednesday morning? Perhaps it would be a good idea to at least have the OPTION of a therapist while in game? Of course, they would have to play…I volunteer me!

  15. EdinMiama  •  Jul 30, 2009 @1:31 pm

    While I understand the sentiment Donna, as a country, we really need to move away from this nanny mentality that insidiously infects the fabric of our society.

    If you do anything in excess and that activity has a negative impact on your life, then, imo, you as an individual should seek to fix your own problem before asking society to create a solution for you and thereby imposing societies will on a group of people who do not share your excess.

  16. Donna  •  Jul 30, 2009 @1:39 pm

    Yes, as an individual you SHOULD see to fix your own problem, but how many drug addicts will go seek help voluntarily? It’s like that with WoW as well. I’m from the U.S. so I’m not sure what this Dr. Graham is all about, but to my knowledge, there are no programs available for game addicts to seek the help from, even if they wanted to where I live.
    I am by far saying, or implying, that if you play x-hours a day, you should be forced to see the in game therapist. THAT would be imposing treatment. But if you wanted to talk to a therapist while you were in game, having that option would be nice. I mean, WoW does mimic real life in almost every other aspect. It is a society in and of itself. I learned that the first week I started to play. And yes, it got way out of hand for me, playing 12-16 hours a day, ignoring my “rl duties” and I did something about it. But I like to think of myself as a unique individual. There are some personalities that are just addictive, and they may not realize that it’s that big of a deal until they start talking about it. I’m just saying it would be nice to have the option if you wanted to take advantage of it.

  17. Chris  •  Aug 3, 2009 @7:21 am

    It’s an interesting thought – I play a level 80 troll Rogue and have done for 4 years now more or less, I met my wife playing WoW (sad blah blah) and we have a couple of kids. I work full time, enjoy it all and yet there are those side effects aren’t there?

    While I was studying my degree part time I did a paper on the Social Effects of MMO’s. I questionairred 50 people from various MMO’s and interviewed 3 very different players. One was a student, one a baker and the third a marketing director. The most surprising find for me (perhaps due to my own ignorance) was that women who play can leave their addiction at the door and do not think about the game too much when not playing.

    All interesting stuff :)

    All the best,
    Ashankt, Bloodhoof-EU
    For the Horde!

1 Trackback

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>