Travis at TJICistan invites us to consider whether we would be less tolerant of government spending if we conceptualized it as expenditure of lives, or years of a life, rather than as "mere" money. Travis is inspired to this by news that the Pentagon spent $47,960 on a portrait of Donald Rumsfeld.
One portrait: one human year.
* Tobacco subsidies: 6.2 human lives per year ($10 million/year)
* Obama’s inauguration: 93 human lives ($150 million – four times more than Bush’s)
* The new visitor’s center in Washington DC: 388 human lives ($621 million)
While TJIC gets points for creativity, there's a fundamental flaw in his plan, and I'm frankly a little surprised that he, as a fellow misanthrope, didn't spot it: lots of people just suck, and any prolonged contact with them tends to ram this point home. Scrapping the International Space Station to save 65,000 lives may seem like the right thing from the tranquility of your porch on a pleasant morning, but when you're behind all of them on the freeway and half of them have those stupid Truck Nutz things, suddenly the Final Frontier is going to seem a whole lot more worth the sacrifice. And I defy anyone to emerge from a committee meeting without concluding that you'd trade four or five lives for some public statuary or something.
So I'll make a counter-proposal. Express costs in terms of things that people generally like. "This project will cost eight bridges-that-won't-fall-down." Or "unless we means-test, this program will cost an additional 48 D-Days." Better yet — go with pets. Because, you know, Americans are generally hardened to all sorts of awful shit happening to people, but it really tugs at their heartstrings when an animal is hurt or abused. So, take the most deranged, incontinent, destructive, illness-prone pet you ever had, total up the lifetime cost of owning it. Say, a dog that chewed up your rare book collection one weekend and had to spend a week at the vet for hip displaysia, or a cat who had several rounds of chemotherapy. Then try to sell government spending by that measurement. "My fellow Americans, this bill would cost ten thousand kitty cats!" "If my colleague succeeds in getting this program passed, it would be as if your faithful Rex, and twenty thousand like him, never put their heads on your knee! The place would be a libertarian paradise in a year.




